Archive for the ‘atheism and totalitarianism’ Category

Atheist Totalitarianism

September 15, 2011

On some estimates, a sixth of the population of the former German Democratic Republic were Mitarbeiter—collaborators with the secret police, the Stasi—and had spied upon and denounced their neighbors, friends, relatives, and even spouses. Once the archives opened and people could read their security dossiers for themselves, they discovered in many cases that those to whom they had relayed their private thoughts had relayed them in turn to the Stasi, in return, practically, for nothing except the informer’s satisfaction of being on the right side of the powerful. Those whom people had thought were their best friends turned out to be the very ones whose denunciation had resulted in their otherwise inexplicable failure to gain promotion in their work, sometimes for decades. Such discoveries were not conducive to a favorable or optimistic view of human nature or the trust upon which a secure social life is built. The GDR, founded on a political theory that made a fetish of human solidarity, turned everyone into an atom in the asocial ether.

Theodore Dalrymple

Why Sam Harris should never be given any position of authority

September 13, 2011

The link between belief and behavior raises the stakes considerably. Some propositions are so dangerous that it may be ethical to kill people for believing them. This may seem an extraordinary claim, but it merely enunciates an ordinary fact about the world in which we live.

Sam Harris, (quoted What the New Atheists Don’t See, Theodore Dalrymple)

The only ‘link’ here is that Sam Harris is a frustrated  totalitarian.  And who would decide which beliefs are so dangerous as to require them to be killed? Plato was like this. A committee of philosopher kings who would decide what’s best for us plebs and kill off those who have the ‘wrong’ beliefs.